Budget is ‘all trick and no treat’ says Laois TD Stanley in the Dáil

Laois TD Brian Stanley has said that the Budget announced this week by the Government is “all trick and no treats”.

 “The month of October is associated with Halloween and children play trick or treat,” said the Independent Republican TD in the Dáil this week.

“However, the Government’s budget is all trick and no treats. That is what we get from the Government.

“There was an election in the previous year and Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael literally went out and bought votes. There was money for everything, there were one-offs and there was helicopter money nearly falling out of the sky.

“There were grants for everything, grants for millionaires and grants for people who did not need them. I never argued against grants for those who need them, but a lot of the money was not targeted and went all over the place. It did not have the effect it should have but it bought votes. That is what it was about.

“This year, there is no General Election and there is nothing for workers,” he added.

“There is nothing for low- and middle-income earners. There is nothing for renters. There is nothing to alleviate the cost of living. 

“On housing, there is no increase in the delivery of affordable or cost-rental housing. The Minister of State knows that the people who are just above the income limit for social housing but not able to get on the ladder to get a mortgage or a loan to buy a house, are the people who are caught here.

“Some of them are now passing middle age and some of them are nearly at retirement age. They have no option but to remain in private rented accommodation, many of whom are at the mercy of rack-renting landlords. All the Government has done for renters is throw away whatever controls were there. From March onwards, it is a free for all. 

“Landlords and developers were looked after in this budget.  There are enhanced corporation tax deals. There are tax cuts, tax reductions and VAT reductions for those developing apartments, as if that would somehow turn on supply. 

“McDonalds, Costa, and Starbucks got VAT reductions. I put this to the Minister of State: if the Government wanted to assist small cafés and restaurants, why did it not reduce VAT on the first three or four million euro of turnover? That could have been done. 

“There are no rent caps for renters and no extra tax relief.  I will give the case of Laois. Recently the Residential Tenancy Board showed there was a 10% increase in rent there which was double the national average over the preceding year. That follows eight successive quarters of high rents increases.

“Workers got no tax relief, particularly those who earn between €24,000 and €70,000. There was nothing for them. What they did get was more local property tax, more carbon tax, no increase to child benefit and an increase for third level fees.

“No matter which way the Government dresses it up, it is an increase in third level fees from €2,000 to €2,500 this year and it should not try to spin it any other way.

“There is also the health situation and the dental crisis. I read what was done for health. There is no specific extra funding for dental services. There is no public dental system worth talking about in Laois.

“I have read the figures out here before on the school dental scheme, the dental treatment service scheme, DTSS, for medical card holders and the PRSI-based scheme. It is absolutely hopeless and is almost non-existent. 

“We are supposed to be almost on the threshold of achieving Sláintecare after ten years. There is no increase in the income threshold for medical cards. Does the Government realise there are people who should have medical cards who cannot go to a doctor?

“The Government has missed low-income workers again. It is nearly 20 years since that threshold was increased. For low- and middle-income earners, there are no medical cards.

“People will ask how the Government got it so wrong, but I think it got it so right. The Government has put money into the pockets of developers, landlords and large hoteliers. This budget looks after the wealthy.

“There is nothing only hardship for people who are on middle and low incomes. That is the reality”. 

SEE ALSO – New signs needed for Castletown as old ones go past their sell-by date